Hope is supposed to have dinner with her ex, in an attempt at closure.  While she waits, she wishes to find her true love on a falling star.  And suddenly, she is in the arms of her childhood friend, Junior, who has moved in next door.  With both men in front of her, she wonders who is her wish come true.

But all of that gets set to the side when she finds out her niece is missing.  Both men offer to help, but only one is any help.