Brek Stryker is having the year of his life.  He is in position to break all of his father's pitching records, and he is engaged to marry the mayor of the town.  Not only is he engaged, but his fiancée is nothing like his last one (Taylor) and he thinks that this is just what he needs.

Taylor is stunned when her sister Eve lets her know Brek is getting married.  She has always thought she would be able to talk with him about why she left him at the alter all those years ago.  Now she might not get the chance.  So she actually bangs up her knee while skiing and comes back to Richmond to make amends.  The problem is that instead of making amends, she ends up making things worse.  She realizes she is still in love with Brek who wants nothing to do with her.  Additionally, Brek’s relief pitcher (Sloan) seems to be hitting on her when he really is attracted to her sister Eve.  Will Sloan and Eve get together? Or will he live up to his love‘em and leave‘em reputation.

 Suddenly things don’t seem to be as good in Brek’s life as in the past.  He is still drawn to Taylor, his fiancée is trying to keep a distance that he doesn’t like, and there is a rumor that his batting nemesis might be traded to his team.   When Taylor ends up in the hospital from her knee injury, he decides that he will be the friend she needs to get better.  Will the rest of his life straighten out? Will they acknowledge the flames that are still between them?